Introduction: What Makes a Great Christmas Movie?
There’s nothing more magical than settling in to watch a Christmas movie during the holiday season.
Images of snowfall, reindeer, presents, and Santa Claus fill our houses, hot cocoa steams on the stove, and the glow of the twinkling lights make everything feel warm and cozy. The perfect conditions to watch a Christmas movie.
But what exactly makes a great Christmas movie? Is it the presence of Santa Claus? A snowy backdrop? A heartfelt story about family, love or redemption? Or is it as simple as just having a movie set during Christmas, even if its themes are more action-packed than holly-jolly?
The debate about what makes a Christmas movie a Christmas movie has raged for longer than we can remember. Never fear, Celtx are here to solve it once and for all in this ultimate showdown of our festive favorites and hidden gems. We’ve even included some of our most loved clips!
From timeless classics to modern hits, animated delights, and offbeat surprises, in today’s post, we’ll explore the movies that make our spirits bright. Whether you’re a traditionalist or love an unconventional pick, there’s something in our lineup for everyone.
So, dust off those sleigh bells and grab your favorite Christmas drink as we dive into Celtx’s Ultimate Christmas Movie Showdown!
Turn your holiday movie dream into a reality with Celtx’s pre-production suite!
The Classics: Timeless Tales
Of course, no Christmas movie list would be complete without the timeless classics that have become an essential part of our holiday traditions. These films capture the essence of Christmas in a way that resonates across the generations. All of them offer messages of hope, kindness, and the enduring spirit of the season.
Miracle on 34th Street (1947)
Most recently featured on our how to write a holiday screenplay post, Miracle on 34th Street is a heartwarming tale of a Macy’s Santa who just might be the real deal.
In this clip, Santa Claus refuses to lie to young Susan after her mother tries to persuade him to tell her he’s not real. When she demands to see his Macy’s employment card, she realizes that he’s been telling the truth all along.
Featuring courtroom drama and touching moments that remind us of the magic of Christmas, it’s a film that won’t be going out of style any time soon!
A Christmas Story (1983)
Ralphie’s quest for a Red Ryder BB gun is filled with hilarious moments and nostalgic charm. In our chosen clip, Ralphie receives the most embarrassing gift imaginable from his Aunt Clara – a pink bunny suit.
From the infamous leg lamp to the infamous pink bunny suit, A Christmas Story encapsulates the chaos and imperfect joy of a family Christmas.
It’s a Wonderful Life (1946)
Back in the golden age of black and white movies, It’s a Wonderful Life is a Christmas classic that transcends generations. The story follows George Baily discovering the value of his life with the help of a guardian angel.
One of her favorite clips is George listing off all his future dreams to Mary, wonder and hope in his eyes.
This movie is a reminder that no one need be alone during the holidays.
New Favorites: Modern Holiday Icons
For a fresh twist on holiday cheer, modern-day holiday movies have brought humor, heart and a contemporary sensibility to our Christmas movie collections.
Our next picks have certainly earned their place alongside the old-school greats.
Elf (2003)
Will Ferrell’s Buddy the Elf is an enthusiastic fish-out-of-water. His childlike wonder and sugary spaghetti recipes have made this movie a fan and Celtx favorite!
This laugh-out-loud comedy ultimately has a sweet message about finding family and spreading joy.
Looking to pen the next great holiday classic? We can help you get started!
Crafting Magic: How to Write a Holiday Movie Script
The Santa Clause (1994)
Tim Allen’s transformation from skeptical dad to the new Santa Claus is a delightful tale for all the family. We see his transformation into Santa throughout the film, and him truly embrace his very important role.
The movie’s imaginative and modern take on the mechanics of the North Pole make it a contemporary classic we must all add to our collections.
Love Actually (2003)
This ensemble rom-com weaves together a host of interconnected stories all about love during the holiday season. It’s equal parts heartwarming and bittersweet, with some finding love, others losing it, and some rediscovering it. But it’s not just romantic relationships spotlighted in Love Actually; from parents and children, to siblings, and forbidden lovers, it truly does cover all types of love.
If you don’t know about the cue card scene, then where have you been?
It’s iconic moments like these that have become synonymous with Christmas for so many of us. I can’t go a year without watching it! Plus, it’s one of the only picks featured from the UK, so I may be a little biased.
Read what Kiera Knightley has to say about this iconic scene 21 years later!
Offbeat and Unexpected Picks
Not every Christmas movie is wrapped in a bow of traditional sentimentality. Some bring action, dark humor, or a quirky twist to the holiday season.
These are perfect movies for those who like their holiday fare with a side of the totally unexpected. So, let’s take a peek!
Die Hard (1988)
You didn’t think we’d skip on the age-old debate – is Die Hard really a Christmas movie? In our eyes, it is (***cue many readers shouting at their screens while reading this with resounding contempt***).
If you need anything else to convince you alongside the holiday party at Nakatomi Plaza and the festive setting, this clip featuring the quote “Now I have a Machine Gun, Ho Ho Ho” should do it. Santa Claus himself is quoted!
All this cements Die Hard on our list of must-watch Christmas movies.
Gremlins (1984)
Offering another unique twist on the holiday spirit, Gremlins sees a cute Mogwai transform into a mischievous Christmas nightmare.
With the film being both adorable and terrifying in equal measure, it has become a horror-comedy classic in many households.
Edward Scissorhands (1990)
Adding a gothic vibe to our Christmas list, Tim Burton’s gothic tale isn’t what we’d call a traditional Christmas story. However, it’s snowy visuals and themes of acceptance and love make it a seasonal favorite. Just take this very wintry scene as Edward makes snow from an ice sculpture.
Who can forget this beautiful and iconic scene?
Bad Santa (2003)
Billy Bob Thornton’s foul-mouthed mall Santa isn’t your average Christmas hero, but this dark comedy’s bold humor has earned it a cult following. Not for a younger audience, the movie is a great laugh for adults.
Despite the cynicism and devious deeds of Bad Santa, underneath is a surprisingly touching story of redemption that aligns itself well with the holiday spirit.
Holiday Horror
If you’re a movie-goer who likes their holiday cheer with a touch of terror, Christmas-themed horror movies are growing in popularity. Here are our recommendations if you’re looking for a scare during the holidays!
Krampus (2015)
A dark comedy horror, Krampus introduces audiences to the titular creature of Alpine folklore. Krampus punishes those who lose their holiday spirit. Some dare to fight it; others prepare to run.
If you’re struggling to embrace the Christmas spirit this year, perhaps give this a watch…
Violent Night (2022)
In this genre-subverting tale, Santa becomes the ultimate action hero. His mission: to take down bad guys and save Christmas. Of course, he uses very seasonal weapons to get the job done, like in this scene:
This over-the-top, blood-soaked holiday flick is a wild ride! Such a wild ride, that it’s coming back for a sequel very soon, set for shooting in 2025.
Holiday or horror? Why not a little bit of both. Bring your story to life with celtx!
Animated: Beloved Cartoons and Stop-Motion Classics
Animation has a special place in holiday movie history, with many of the most iconic Christmas stories brought to live through colorful, imaginative visuals that delight both adults and kids alike.
Let’s check out our favorite picks:
A Charlie Brown Christmas (1965)
A TV special that has stood the test of time, A Charlie Brown Christmas reminds us of the true meaning of Christmas with its simple yet profound storytelling, reminding us of the simple and very best of Christmas, like this snowflake scene.
The special begins with Charlie believing Christmas is too commercialized. To convince others, he decides to direct the school play where he learns the true meaning of Christmas.
How the Grinch Stole Christmas (1966)
Returning to the much-loved redemption arc, Dr. Seuss’s classic tale of finding holiday cheer first came to life on the screen in this animated short.
Narrated by Boris Karloff, this adaptation of the story showcases The Grinch’s heartwarming transformation. It was so popular, that we were treated to the also beloved live-action version starring Jim Carrey in 2000, and the recently animated The Grinch (2018).
Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer (1964)
This stop-motion gem is one of the most famous holiday specials of all time. We’re introduced to the enchanting Island of Misfit Toys, and larger than life characters like Yukon Cornelius.
Packed with memorable songs just like A Holly Jolly Christmas, it’s a story that will be viewed for many years to come.
Frosty the Snowman (1969)
A cheerful tale of a snowman who comes to life and spreads joy is a must-watch every Christmas!
Many of us will already know the catchy theme song and heartfelt message which has endured for nearly 60 years.
Holiday Specials
Of course, we couldn’t leave it there with the holiday specials! Christmas episodes and specials of popular franchises are an increasingly common trends, giving fans of many different IPs a festive twist on their favorite characters and worlds.
First, let’s head back to 1978, and the polarizing Star Wars Holiday Special. Love it or hate it, this infamous special has earned its place in pop culture history, and our showdown list!
Or if you’d prefer a more recent addition, why not check out The Guardians of the Galaxy Holiday Special from 2022, or Toy Story That Time Forgot (2014), where the heroes of both franchises are challenged to subdue holiday chaos and enjoy the season!
Let us know your festive picks over on our social media pages!
The Great Debate: What Defines a Christmas Movie?
Now that we’ve been all around the realm of Christmas movies, we return to the big question – what truly makes a Christmas movie? Does it need to revolve around holiday themes, or is a Christmas setting enough?
One key factor is the emotional core of the story. Great Christmas movies often explore themes of togetherness, redemption, and the power of love or generosity. Even the more offbeat picks in our list touch on these ideas, albeit in unconventional ways.
Ultimately, the beauty of Christmas movies lies in their diversity – there’s something for everyone, from nostalgia to laugh out loud comedy, thrilling action to the totally unexpected.
Conclusion: The Magic of Holiday Storytelling
Christmas movies are more than entertainment. They connect us, invite reflection, and celebrate the magic of the holiday season. From Miracle on 34th Street to Edward Scissorhands, each brings unique joy to holiday traditions.
But we’re not quite done with our recommendations for the perfect holiday movie night. At Celtx HQ, our must-watches include The Muppet Christmas Carol for its humor and heart, The Holiday for the perfect rom-com fix, The Nightmare Before Christmas for unforgettable songs, and Jim Carrey’s How The Grinch Stole Christmas for its hilarious charm.
Grab a snack, settle in, and explore Christmas cinema. Classics or unconventional picks, there’s no wrong way to embrace the season. Happy holidays!
We came with gifts: more amazing Celtx blogs!
- For horror lovers: 10 of the Best Hidden Horror Gems (According to Celtx)
- Looking for a laugh? The Best SNL Skits of All Time: Celebrating 50 Years of Laughs
- Add a little romance to the watch list: Romantic Comedy Plot Structures: Classic vs. Contemporary
